Home

A Reconsideration of the Hohle Fels Ropemaking Tool

Of course, that doesn’t mean that’s the only thing it could be.
But compared to saying that it’s a symbol of power or some sort of artwork,
I think the rope hypothesis is a pretty good one.

Rope making in the Aurignacian of Central Europe more than 35,000 years ago
Nicholas Conard - 2024[1]

 

 

Introduction


Figure 1. Hohle Fels Artifact.

 

In 2015, a worked piece of ivory was found at Hohle FelsMaps in Germany, by Prof. Nicholas Conard and colleagues. Every few years, the story gets dusted off, and the hypothesis becomes more of a reality in the echo chamber of the Internet.

 

What I tell you three times is true.
The Hunting of the Snark
Lewis Carroll - 1871

 

Year Author(s) Article
2016 Conard and Malina Außergewöhnliche neue Funde aus den aurignacienzeitlichen Schiten vom Hohle Fels bei Schelklingen.
2016 Milligan, Mark Researchers discover how rope was made 40,000 years ago
2016 The Archaeology News Network 40,000-year-old rope-making tool discovered in Germany
2016 The History Blog 40,000-year-old rope-making tool found in famed German cave
2017 Gugliotta, Guy Link to the Past: Evidence of Humanity's Oldest Ropes Unearthed
2020 McKie, Robin Take a tusk, drill holes, weave a rope – and change the course of history
2021 Boucherat, Toomaï Functional Study of an Archaeological Tool of Mammoth Ivory with Four Spiral Holes
2024 Conard and Rots Rope making in the Aurignacian of Central Europe more than 35,000 years ago
2024 Conard and Rots Supplementary Material
2024 Thorsberg, Christian Stone Age People Used This 35,000-Year-Old Woolly Mammoth Tusk Tool to Make Rope, Scientists Say
2024 Bower, Bruce A four-holed piece of ivory provides a glimpse into ancient rope-making
2026 Taub, Benjamin Rope, twine and thread: Invisible technologies of the Stone Age

There are also a surprising number of AI generated videos that say this ivory relic is a ropemaking tool.

As someone with an interest in traditional ropemaking, I find the unquestioned repetition of a hypothesis concerning. Even Professor Conard, the discoverer of the artifact, has reservations, "...that doesn’t mean that’s the only thing it could be."[1]

Maslow's Hammer

Maslow's Hammer states "if all you have is a hammer, everything looks like a nail."[2] The converse is also true. If you need to drive a nail, everything looks like a hammer.

I have used an adjustable wrench to drive a nail to hang a picture. It can be done. But the hand grip is awkward, the sliding jaw doesn't give a solid hit. You have to work around the adjusting screw knob. It works, but this is not the job this tool was designed for.

You can open a champagne bottle with a saber. [3] [4] It can be done, but there are simpler and safer ways to open that bottle, with less extravagant tools. Or no tools at all.

You can cook dinner on the hot engine of your car[5], but the wheels, the back seat, the turn signals; these are clues that cooking was not top-most on the automobile designer's mind.

Other groups have duplicated the Hohle Fels tool, and used it to make twisted rope.[6] But just because the tool could be made to produce rope, it does not prove that that was the designed use, nor that the tool was actually ever used to make rope.

So the question becomes; are there design features of the Hohle Fels tools that are not compatible with making rope?

Counter Indications

There are many ways to make rope without any tools at all, or just using a simple stick. These methods are still practiced today.

Technique Region Video
Finger Twisting

Australia String Making
Finger Twisting

United Kingdom How to make lime bark cordage
Finger Twisting

Shetland Islands DA MAKKIN O' A KESHIE
Thigh Rolling

Belgium Making cordage by thigh rolling
Thigh Rolling
Team Twisting

North America Hands-on History | The Art of Powhatan Cordage
Team Twisting

Nepal Traditional Rope Making for Himalayan Honey Hunting | Ancient Village Skills of Nepal
Stick Twisting

Ecuador Creating trenzas (braided rope) from paja in Urbina, Ecuador
Stick Twisting

Sweden Make 3-ply rope by hand without any special tools
Palm Twisting

Japan Old Japan - Making rope by hand
Palm Twisting

Mongolia Hair rope part one

A carved tool, with spiral grooved holes is not necessary for making rope. Nor is it any simpler than many ropemaking techniques used today.

Papers from 2015[7] and 2019[8] talk about the larger collection of "Bâtons Percés" from all over Europe. Some with a single hole, some with up to seven holes. Some holes have spiral grooves; some holes have no grooves. If the Hohle Fels ivory was intended to be a rope making tool, then it follows that all the other similar tools had that as their intended purpose also. The distribution of Bâtons Percés, across time (50,000 to 5,000 years ago[7]) and space (Europe north of Spain and Italy[8]), indicate a wide-spread adoption of the pattern. Yet for the last few thousand years, there is no evidence of anyone using a tool with spiraling grooved holes to make rope.

The Holes

"Each of the holes is lined with deep, and precisely cut spiral incisions. The new find demonstrates that these elaborate carvings are technological features of rope-making equipment rather than just decoration."[9]

Counting back from the broken end, towards the "handle", in Figure 1, above, Hole Number 4 presents a problem. All of the holes have "precisely cut spiral incisions" rotating clockwise as you go towards the middle of the hole. Except for Hole Number 4. The grooves on one side match the pattern of the other holes, but on the other side (Figure 1, bottom) the grooves turn the other direction. This feature seldom gets mentioned.

If "The grooves help ... orient the fibers...",[1] then Hole Number 4 is a failure. The direction of the grooves reverses in the middle of the hole. The ancient craftsman carved the entire tool over many hours, maybe days, and carved at least three of the grooves backwards. No effort was made to correct this mistake. Perhaps the grooves were designed to do something other than help orient fibers.

But the direction of the grooves doesn't really matter when making rope. As has been mentioned elsewhere,[10] if you pull a bunch of fibers straight through a constricted space, the fibers align with the direction of the pull.

Illustration showing straight line path of fibers pulled in a 
straight line.
Figure 2. Straight Line Path of Fibers Pulled in a Straight Line.

 

Videos of people making rope with replicas of the Hohle Fels ivory,[6] [11] clearly show people twisting each of the three or four strands before they reach the tool, and another person is twisting the assembled rope after it exits the tool. All of this twisting and combining can be done without the tool at all. Any tool.

Uniform Size

A nice feature of rope is that it's easy to make a different diameter rope to meet your specific need. Everything from sewing clothing to lashing together shelter and hauling heavy loads.

If this artifact actually made rope, that rope would be about 3/4th inch (18mm) in diameter. Nothing thicker, since more fibers wouldn't fit through the holes. Nothing thinner, because the fibers wouldn't be pressed against the supposedly important grooves. For reference, three-ply 3/4" Manila rope has a safe working rating of over 800 pounds (360 kg.). The breaking load is over 4,000 pounds (1814 kg.)

What was the huge demand for one single, uniform, size of rope 35,000 years ago that would justify the effort to make a single use tool?

Asymmetric Grooves

The grooves are not arranged symmetrically around the hole. This pattern of grooves is echoed in many other perforated batons from across Europe.[7] [8] The grooves start and stop in line with the artifact's long axis. This means the grooves, as they go through the hole, only go along one side of the hole. The other side is smooth(ish). If a bundle of fiber is packed into a hole, the grooves are only going to contact one half of the bundle. Why would you build a tool that only "twists" or "aligns" part of the fibers from each bundle?

 

Conclusion

The Hohle Fels ivory artifact is one of a vast collection of similar ancient worked items. Someone spent a lot of time carving this tool. If it was hard to make rope without something like this (it isn't), and if Hole Number 4 had grooves with a constant direction of twist (it doesn't), and the grooves provided twist (they don't), and the grooves were evenly distributed around the holes (they aren't), then I would agree with Professor Conard, and "... think the rope hypothesis is a pretty good one."[1] But there are so many reasons this probably wasn't designed to make rope that I think the hypothesis needs to be re-worked.

Bibliography

1
Conard and Rots (2024)
Rope making in the Aurignacian of Central Europe more than 35,000 years ago

2
Wikipedia
Law of the Instrument

3
Wikipedia
Sabrage

4
Malin, Josh (2014)
Champagne Sabering

5
Maynard, Chris (2008)
Manifold Destiny: The One, the Only, Guide to Cooking on Your Car Engine!
ISBN-13 978-1416596233

6
Pointer, Sally (2024)
Palaeolithic Rope-making Experiment

7
Hitchcock, Don (2015)
Bâtons Percés

8
Lucas, C., Galway-Witham, J., et al. (2019)
Investigating the use of Paleolithic perforated batons: new evidence from Gough’s Cave (Somerset, UK)

9
Universitaet Tübingen (2016)
How rope was made 40,000 years ago

10
Keith (2020)
History of Ropemaking

11
Taub, Benjamin (2026)
Rope, twine and thread: Invisible technologies of the Stone Age


 

Appendix - Bad AI Videos

A partial list of AI generated videos that mention the Hohle Fels ivory artifact as a ropemaking tool.

The Stone Age Tool That May Have Made Rope.
Four Holes, One Rope..."
How Did Ice Age Humans Make Rope?
The 40,000 Year-Old Rope Machine
35,000-Year-Old Rope-Making Secret Discovered
Humans Invented Rope 40,000 Years Ago
How Ancient Humans Invented a Machine 35,000 Years Ago
They Made Rope 35,000 Years Ago.
How Did Ancient Humans Make Rope?
The 35,000-Year-Old Mammoth Ivory Tool...
How Did Ancient Humans Make Rope
The First Rope Was Twisted From Grass

 

 

Colophon Contacts